KontorBund
The Library

Quad9's withdrawal from France and the DNS blocking order behind it

Last checked25 October 2026
KeeperOpen — keeper wanted
StatusJudgment of 21 October 2026 — appeal pending

The short version

Quad9, the Swiss non-profit that runs a free public DNS resolver, said on 22 October 2026 that it will stop serving users in France from 24 November 2026 rather than block domain names for the sports broadcaster beIN Sports. Behind that sits a judgment of 21 October 2026 (Tribunal judiciaire de Paris, RG 26/11882), which attaches a penalty of €1,000 per day to a blocking injunction from 13 May 2026 that Quad9 has not carried out. The order is addressed to the resolver, not to the sites — and the answer Quad9 chose is to leave the market. We read the October judgment and Quad9's own post in full. Neither of them decides whether blocking should have been ordered at all: the October judgment deals only with whether the May injunction was executed, and sends the proportionality argument to the appeal.

What happened, in dates

Every date below is taken from the judgment of 21 October 2026, from Quad9's post of 22 October 2026, or from the trade reporting listed at the end — and it says which.

13 May 2026 — the underlying order
The president of the Tribunal judiciaire de Paris ordered Quad9, at the request of beIN Sports France, to put in place "all measures suitable to prevent" access from French territory to a list of sites and IPTV services, within three days at most of the order being served, "in particular by blocking the sites reachable through the six domain names and subdomains listed by the court" (notamment par le blocage des sites accessibles par les 6 noms de domaine et sous-domaines associés listés par le tribunal). It ran to the end of the WTA tennis season, at that point fixed at 14 November 2026. Case number RG 26/02207 — known to us only as the 21 October judgment recites it.
26 June 2026 — a bailiff's report
A procès-verbal de constat recording that two of the ordered domain names could be reached through Quad9 (judgment, para. 13, describing beIN's evidence). beIN also reports a formal notice of 12 June 2026 (para. 8, as beIN's assertion).
4 September 2026 — Quad9 is summoned
Authorised by an order of 1 September 2026, beIN had Quad9 summoned under the accelerated procedure on the merits (procédure accélérée au fond, article 481-1 of the code of civil procedure) to obtain enforcement of the May judgment through a penalty. Hearing on 1 October 2026, decision reserved to 21 October 2026.
21 October 2026 — the judgment
Third chamber, third section: an injunction to carry out the May blocking measures, backed by a penalty of €1,000 per day of delay from the day of the ruling until the end of the ordered measures. The court reserves the power to liquidate the penalty later. Nothing is awarded on costs.
22 October 2026 — Quad9's announcement
A post titled "Farewell, France", published in French as "Ce n'est qu'un au revoir, la France". In its own words: "Starting November 24, Quad9 will no longer be able to offer its free cyberprotection service to users located in France." The post says the ruling "forces Quad9 to block the recursive DNS resolution for a number of domain names for users located in France", that it "will not block the domains in question", and that an appeal is pending.
14 and 24 November 2026 — the two end dates
14 November 2026 is where the ordered blocking ends, as the October judgment records it (the last match of the WTA 2026 tournament, which the judgment gives as running from 2 January to 14 November 2026). 24 November 2026 is the Tuesday on which Quad9 says it stops serving France. The judgment does not mention the second date, and the post does not explain the gap.
24 October 2026 — the report this note started from
Reclaim The Net, "Quad9 to Leave France Over DNS Blocking Order". We could not open the page: it returned an access error. Nothing on this page rests on it, and where our findings differ from the framing that reached us, the documents below win — the order is a court order in a civil case brought by a broadcaster, not a regulator's blocking order.

The order, and the judgment that enforced it

Two documents, two judges, one obligation. The May 2026 order created the duty; the October 2026 judgment is about the fact that Quad9 did nothing to meet it.

What was ordered, in the judgment's own recital
Access to the listed sites and IPTV services had to be prevented "from French territory, including in the French overseas collectivities, regions and departments, and in Saint-Pierre-et-Miquelon, with the exception of the territories of New Caledonia, Wallis and Futuna and French Polynesia", by "any effective means", and also against users "by reason of a contract taken in that territory". So the order is territorial, and it reaches sites not yet identified at the date of the decision.
Fifty-eight names, six of them listed
The 13 May 2026 order listed six domain names and subdomains. beIN's evidence in September 2026 covered 58 names in total — those in the judgment "and those notified afterwards by ARCOM" — and showed, on beIN's case, that only six of them could not be reached through Quad9 from France. Quad9's own technical director attested on 25 September 2026 that none of the names had been blocked, "at the date of those checks, nor at any earlier date".
Why the court ordered the penalty
Because nothing had been attempted. Para. 18: a resolver under an obligation of means "affirms that it puts none in place in order to execute the decision", and "this single circumstance justifies" the penalty. Para. 16: Quad9 said geolocated blocking was impossible, "but does not demonstrate it", and appeared to contradict itself, having described its own automated filtering limited to cybersecurity.
What the court refused to look at
Two arguments were declared inoperative rather than rejected on the merits: that Quad9 had appealed the May judgment (para. 14), and that the measures imposed were disproportionate (para. 17) — the second because that belongs to the cour d'appel de Paris, which has the case. Also inoperative: Quad9's offers to agree technical terms with beIN under ARCOM's auspices (para. 15), the court holding that this is about executing a judgment.

"Provisionally enforceable" is the whole sentence that matters

The May judgment carries provisional enforcement by operation of law, and the October judgment is itself enforceable by provision (article R.131-4 of the code of civil enforcement procedures). An appeal therefore does not buy time, and the court said so in one line. If you are on the receiving end of an order like this, the appeal is a second track running beside a clock that is already ticking.

€1,000 a day, and the rate that was asked for

What the court fixed
€1,000 per day of delay, from the pronouncement of the 21 October 2026 decision until the end of the measures ordered — with the power to liquidate the penalty reserved for later (para. 21 and the operative part).
What beIN asked for
€10,000 per day of delay and per domain name or subdomain remaining accessible through Quad9, three days after service — and not only for the names in the May order but also for names already notified, and yet to be notified, by ARCOM under articles L.333-10 III and L.333-11 of the code du sport. Over 58 names that rate would come to as much as €580,000 a day; the French trade reports put that figure together, and Quad9's post describes the court as having "reduced the financial penalty, from €580,000 to €1,000 per day".
What Quad9 says it is facing
Its own arithmetic: €1,000 a day "until the blocking concludes on November 14 (i.e., 24,000 euros)", before legal defence. Counting days from 22 October to 14 November inclusive gives 24 days — the same figure, and that counting is ours. Quad9 also says it faces "approximately 20 different lawsuits" in France, against it and other recursive resolver operators, demanding the blocking of hundreds of names.
Costs, either way
beIN's claim under article 700 of the code of civil procedure was rejected, and each party bears its own costs — so a small non-profit still pays its own lawyers for a case it has not lost yet.
An ordered amount and a requested rate are different things. The judgment records €1,000 per day as the sum it imposes; the €580,000 appears as the top of what beIN asked for, computed per name across 58 names. Nothing we read records €580,000 per day as an amount ever due.

What a DNS blocking duty means for a small provider

This section adds no obligation to anyone. It separates two things the headlines run together: the duty to block, and the remedy of leaving the market. The first is a legal question for a court; the second is a business decision, and it does not answer the first.

The duty attaches to whoever answers the query
The addressee here is a recursive resolver: a non-profit in Zürich, with no list of French users and, on its own account, no way to build one. The sites were not parties. If you run resolution — a public resolver, a self-hosted instance you hand to customers, an open-source resolver shipped as a default — you are the kind of intermediary this order reached for, and being established outside France is not itself the answer: Quad9 is Swiss and was summoned in Paris.
It is a duty of means, and the means have to be shown
The court did not ask for success; it asked what had been attempted, and found that nothing had. The practical lesson is narrow and useful: an argument that blocking cannot be done reliably has to arrive as evidence, not as a description of the internet. That is also where Quad9's case is weakest on the documents — it rested on an attestation that no blocking had occurred, which proves the failure rather than the impossibility.
The clock is short and the meter runs per day
Three days from service in the May order; a per-day penalty from the ruling onwards; provisional enforcement on both. For a provider deciding what to do, the useful preparation is not a position on copyright but a short written record of what you can and cannot technically do, produced before anyone asks.
Leaving is a remedy of sorts — not a defence
Quad9 announced a withdrawal; the judgment is unchanged by the announcement, the court kept its power to liquidate the penalty, and the blocking calendar in the judgment runs to 14 November 2026 while the departure is dated 24 November 2026. We print both dates and draw no further conclusion: whether a withdrawal affects anything is not decided in either document we read.
What this is not. It is not a finding that DNS resolvers must filter, and not a finding that they must not. The May order is one judge's decision in one civil case, brought by a broadcaster; the October judgment only asks whether that order was carried out. Requests of this shape appear to be routine rather than exceptional in France — on Quad9's own count, around twenty cases are pending — which is the reason a resolver, a host or an open-source project shipping resolution into France should know the mechanics above.

What we could not establish

The May 2026 judgment
We have not read it. Everything above about it is the 21 October judgment's recital plus the trade reports. Its exact wording, the six domain names, its operative articles and whether it also binds Google in the same decision (the trade press says it does; the recital names only Quad9) are all open. The article of the code du sport that beIN invoked, L.333-10, appears in beIN's submissions and in the court's citation of L.333-10 II for the penalty — we have not read the statute.
ARCOM's part
The judgment records that the 58 names were covered by the May judgment "and by ARCOM subsequently", and beIN's submissions describe an ARCOM notification power under articles L.333-10 III and L.333-11 of the code du sport. We have read no ARCOM decision, notification or publication, and we cannot say when those notifications were made or on what basis. Quad9's post names the court as the source of the order and mentions ARCOM only in its closing call to action.
The domain names, and who else is affected
None of the domain names are in our hands; we have not published a list and cannot check what is or is not blocked. Whether Google, said to have been ordered alongside Quad9 in May 2026, complied, is unknown to us.
What withdrawal means in practice
Quad9 says it "will no longer serve French users" and that it keeps no user database, so how a French user is identified for the purpose of being refused is not something we have verified. Whether the departure is total — every service, or only some — is likewise unverified.
The appeal
Pending, on Quad9's account, with the cour d'appel de Paris seised of the May judgment (para. 17). We have no appeal file, no hearing date and no outcome, and we do not know whether the withdrawal has any effect on it.
The status of the document itself
We read the judgment as a PDF published by Quad9, not from a court database. The file number matches that given in the trade press, but we cannot say from our own inspection whether the copy is the version as served on the parties or the court's published text.
The report we started from
The Reclaim The Net page would not load for us. Its headline and one-line summary are all we saw, and where it or the briefing behind this page suggested a regulator's blocking order or an unknown issuing authority, the judgment settles the point: a civil court, at a broadcaster's request.

Documents we would still like

A source we can open beats ten pages of commentary. These are the texts that would let this note stop hedging.

1. The judgment of 13 May 2026 (RG 26/02207)
Would settle the six names, the operative article, the three-day deadline and whether Google is bound in the same decision.
2. The ARCOM notifications
Any decision or notification by which the list grew from six names to 58, and the provision relied on. The judgment attributes the growth to ARCOM without publishing the instrument.
3. The appeal file
Any ruling of the cour d'appel de Paris on the May judgment, and any request to suspend enforcement.
4. Any liquidation order
The judgment reserves the right to liquidate the €1,000-per-day penalty; a liquidation decision would show what was actually payable.
5. Quad9's own statement — held
Obtained: the post of 22 October 2026 and the judgment PDF it links to. If Quad9 restates its position, or if it publishes how the withdrawal is implemented, this page should be revised rather than left standing.
6. A decision in one of the other cases
Quad9 counts around twenty pending suits against resolvers in France. A reasoned decision on whether a resolver can be made to filter would be worth more than any of the above.

Sources

  1. Quad9 — “Farewell, France” Blog post, published 22 October 2026. Source for the withdrawal on 24 November 2026, for the description of the ruling as one "in favor of beIN" that "forces Quad9 to block the recursive DNS resolution for a number of domain names for users located in France", for the sentence "we will not block the domains in question", for the characterisation of a recursive resolver as "a neutral and passive service" (Quad9's own words, not a legal finding), for the statement that compliance is "technically unfeasible", for the figures €580,000 and €1,000 per day as Quad9 frames them, for its own estimate of 24,000 euros to 14 November, for the pending appeal, for the count of about 20 further lawsuits against resolvers in France, and for its account of the German case against Sony Music Entertainment GmbH from 2021 to 2023. Read in full for this note
  2. Tribunal judiciaire de Paris, 3e chambre, 3e section — jugement du 21 octobre 2026, RG n° 26/11882 (PDF, French) The backbone of this note, seven pages, read in full. Source for the parties (S.A.S. beIN Sports France against Fondation Quad9), the case numbers RG 26/11882 and RG 26/02207, the accelerated procedure under article 481-1 of the code of civil procedure, the hearing of 1 October 2026, the terms of the 13 May 2026 order as recited — the three-day deadline, "par tout moyen efficace, et notamment par le blocage des sites accessibles par les 6 noms de domaine et sous-domaines associés listés par le tribunal", the territorial carve-outs, the WTA season of 2 January to 14 November 2026 — beIN's request of €10,000 per day and per domain name or subdomain, the figure of 58 names, the bailiff's report of 26 June 2026, Quad9's attestation of 25 September 2026, the reasoning at paras. 14 to 18 and 21, the €1,000 per day penalty until the end of the measures, the reserved power to liquidate, the rejection of the claims under article 700 and the provisional enforceability under article R.131-4. Note: published by Quad9, not obtained from a court database
  3. Next — “DNS : Quad9 quitte la France après avoir été condamnée face à BeIN pour défaut de blocage” (French) Specialist tech outlet, 23 October 2026. Source for the 13 May 2026 order having been addressed to Google as well as Quad9, for beIN's request of €10,000 per day per name amounting on Quad9's reading to €580,000 a day, for the blocking running to the end of the tournament on 14 November and the three-day implementation window, for the September 2026 summons, for the court's calculation of the penalty from the pronouncement of the decision, and for the 2024 precedent of OpenDNS suspending its service in France after a decision obtained by Canal+. Read in full for this note
  4. Télé Satellite et Numérique — “Piratage : condamné à une astreinte à la demande de beIN Sports, Quad9 quitte la France” (French) Trade publication, 22 October 2026. Source for the list having been extended to 58 domain names, for Quad9 having blocked none of them, for the €580,000 figure as up to €10,000 per day per name, for Quad9's own estimate of €24,000 excluding defence costs, and for the note that the same court recently refused penalties sought by beIN against VPN providers and Cloudflare. Third-party characterisation, used only where the judgment does not speak. Read in full for this note
  5. heise online — “Censorship ruling prompts DNS service Quad9 to leave France” English edition, 22 October 2026. Secondary. Source for the chamber (third chamber), for the formulation of the case numbers, for the scope of the measure in the overseas territories and Saint-Pierre-et-Miquelon with the three excluded territories, and for the reading that French users will be blocked from lookups "wherever possible". Its headline characterisation of the ruling is its own. Read in full for this note
  6. Reclaim The Net — “Quad9 to Leave France Over DNS Blocking Order” Dated 24 October 2026 in the material that reached us. Not readable for us — the page returned an access error, and only the headline and a one-line summary were visible. Listed because it is where this note began, and because nothing here rests on it.
  7. KontorBund — Arcom's DSA enforcement in France: the Mym information request of 14 October 2026 The same regulator, a different instrument: an information request under the Digital Services Act, not a blocking order, and no finding of a breach
  8. KontorBund — Poland's DSA implementation acts and the ministry's platform enforcement push Blocking with immediate enforceability in another Member State: what a national blocking power looks like when it is written into the statute rather than read into an existing one

Tell us what we got wrong

What this note needs most is the judgment of 13 May 2026 (RG 26/02207), and after that any ARCOM notification that carried the list from six names to 58. The third thing is the appeal: whether the cour d'appel de Paris has ruled, and whether anyone asked it to suspend enforcement. A source we can open beats ten pages of commentary.