KontorBund
The Library

Do you own your digital games? Licences, resale and server shutdowns

Last checked19 October 2026
KeeperOpen — keeper wanted
StatusRead it

The short version

When you buy a game digitally you buy a licence to use a copy, on terms the rights holder sets — including how long the online part is meant to run. EU law requires nobody to keep a game running after its commercial life ends: on 16 June 2026 the Commission declined to propose such an obligation and said it would explore a self-regulatory code of conduct instead. What EU law does require is that you are told what you are buying, that the terms are fair, and that what you get conforms to the contract — which is where a shutdown earlier than a buyer could reasonably expect becomes a refund, not a resurrection. There is no right to resell a digital game. The US Power To The Players Act is a proposal announced on 15 October 2026 with no published text, and it is not law in the US, let alone in the EU.

What you buy when you buy a game

“Buy” on a storefront button and “own” in a sale contract are not the same word, and the difference is not a trick invented by games publishers. A video game is protected by copyright, and copyright gives the rights holder the say over how the work is made available. The Commission put the boundary in its own words in the reply of 16 June 2026: “the choice of whether and how to distribute or otherwise make available a protected work such as a video game lies with the rights holders within the limits set by the legal framework”, and rights holders are in principle free to impose “temporal limits or other conditions” on the uses they authorise.

So what you receive is a licence: a permission, defined by the end-user terms and by what the seller told you before you paid. What you do not receive is the servers, the authentication system, the anti-cheat, the third-party licensed trademarks or the code that runs the online part — the Commission notes expressly that these “are not transferred to consumers at the time of purchase”. That is the whole of the ownership question, and it is why “buy” and “own” can diverge without anyone breaking a rule.

The licence is not lawless. The terms can say a great deal, but they cannot mislead you about what you are buying, and terms that create a significant imbalance in the parties' rights are not binding on a consumer. Those two limits do more work than the word “ownership” would; the sections below are about how.

What happens at shutdown today

The starting point is a negative, stated by the Commission: EU consumer protection legislation “does not set specific requirements for the duration of the supply of digital content and services, including online video games, nor does it require traders to ensure that consumers can continue using digital content and services once their commercial supply has ended”. Four instruments then do the actual work.

Before the sale — Consumer Rights Directive
Clear and comprehensible information about the main characteristics and functionality of the digital content, the duration of the contract and the conditions for terminating it. This is pre-contract information: it belongs in the listing, not on a support page discovered afterwards.
Before and during — Unfair Commercial Practices Directive
No omitting material information the average consumer needs to take an informed decision. The duty continues after the sale: once a provider has decided to discontinue a game, the Commission says the UCPD “requires them to inform consumers accordingly”, because that affects decisions about in-game purchases.
The termination clause — Unfair Contract Terms Directive
Terms letting a provider end the service with wide discretion, without a sufficiently clear and transparent justification or without reasonable notice, may create a significant imbalance and are then not binding on the consumer. That is a case-by-case assessment, not a blanket ban.
After the shutdown — Digital Content Directive
Digital content must possess the qualities and performance features normal for its type, including “accessibility” and “continuity”. A discontinuation sooner than the consumer could reasonably expect can therefore be a lack of conformity, and the consumer can ask for a proportionate refund of the price paid in advance — including unused in-game currency. The Directive applies from 1 January 2022; there is still no Court of Justice judgment interpreting it, and the Commission's report on its application, covering discontinuation, is due by the end of 2026.

A worked example of the problem, not of the remedy: NBA 2K25, released in September 2024, is pulled from digital stores on 30 October 2026 and its servers are switched off on 1 January 2027. MyCAREER and MyTEAM stop working with them, because progression and virtual currency sit behind the connection, while Play Now, MyNBA, The W and MyWNBA remain playable offline. Nobody obliged 2K to do otherwise; what a buyer's rights are worth here depends on what was promised at the point of sale.

“If it shuts down, I get my money back”

Not automatically, and not in full. The refund follows a finding that the discontinuation was not in conformity with what the buyer could reasonably expect — judged against the nature of the game, how it was marketed and the period it stayed available — and it is proportionate to the unexpired part. A term that told the buyer the lifespan before they paid also shapes what they could reasonably expect.

“Offline mode is a legal duty in the EU”

It is not. No EU instrument requires an offline patch, a server handover or a playable end state. Single-player games that only need a connection to authenticate the player could plausibly stay functional — the Commission records consumer representatives making exactly that point — but plausible is not required.

Stop Killing Games: what it asks, where it stands

Stop Killing Games is a campaign. Its legal instrument is a European citizens' initiative, registered under the name “Stop Destroying Videogames”, and the distinction matters because the reply answers the initiative and treats the campaign as context.

What it asked for
That publishers selling or licensing videogames in the EU be required to leave them “in a functional (playable) state”, and not to disable them remotely “before providing reasonable means to continue functioning”. It said expressly that it does not seek ownership, intellectual-property rights or monetisation rights, and the organisers told the Commission it targets games yet to be developed, not titles already on sale.
The dates
Registered 19 June 2024 (Implementing Decision (EU) 2024/1824); signatures collected 31 July 2024 to 31 July 2025; submitted to the Commission 26 January 2026 after national verification; public hearing in Parliament 16 April 2026; plenary debate 21 May 2026.
The answer
16 June 2026 — Communication C/2026/4110, published as C/2026/3601 of 9 July 2026. A proposal for a legal act obliging publishers to keep games playable “would not be proportionate”, for reasons of intellectual-property rights, trade secrets and know-how, cost, and cybersecurity and safety risks once support ends.
What follows instead
Stakeholder exchanges, to be initiated by the end of 2026, to explore a self-regulatory/industry-led code of conduct on end-of-life management — possibly storefront labelling about discontinuation and partnerships with cultural heritage institutions. No draft, no signatories, no enforcement. A second track: the Commission's report on the Digital Content Directive, also by the end of 2026.

The full file, with the reply's structure and quotes, is in the Stop Killing Games note.

Resale: what exists and what does not

In the EU, there is no right to resell a digital game. Nothing in the Commission's reply creates one, and the reply is not where such a right would come from: it deals with playability and with existing consumer law. Copyright, the Commission notes, allows rights holders to license use “unless an exception or limitation applies or the principle of exhaustion applies” — a hint at a legal debate, not a resale regime.

A resale right is also not just a sentence in a law. Someone has to run the market, prove a transferred copy is genuine, decide whether the seller keeps access, and settle what the rights holder is owed for the second sale. Physical discs carry the answer on the disc; digital entitlements carry it in an account. That is the gap between “you may transfer” and a working second-hand market, and no published proposal fills it.

What does exist that looks like it: platform-to-platform transfers of an account are usually barred by terms, refunds are a contractual or consumer-law remedy rather than a resale, and a licence that permits transferring a copy is a decision by the seller, not a right of the buyer. Check the terms you actually accepted before promising a customer anything.

Where the proposals stand

Two of these are law, one is a Commission position and two are proposals — one with no text at all. The table keeps them apart, because the most common mistake on this topic is treating a press release as a statute.

InstrumentWhereStatusWhat it does
CRD, UCPD, UCTD, DCD EU In force Information before the sale and during it, fair-terms review, conformity and a proportionate refund. No playability obligation.
Commission reply to the ECI EU Adopted 16 June 2026 No legislative proposal on playability; a self-regulatory code to be explored, exchanges by end of 2026; DCD report by end of 2026.
Power To The Players Act US, federal Announced 15 October 2026 — no bill number, no text As reported: FTC-directed ownership standard, functional offline mode before decommissioning, digital transfer and resale. Not law.
AB 2426 California Adopted 2024 Transparency: traders must clearly inform consumers when a digital purchase confers only a licence to access content, not ownership rights.
AB 1921 (“Protect our games act”) California Under consideration as recorded by the Commission in June 2026 Addresses the discontinuation of video games. We could not verify its current status.
Neither US item is EU law, and neither binds a seller in the EU. They matter to a European studio only in the way platform terms matter: storefronts and engines set one policy for all markets, so a US rule, if one ever passed, would surface in the terms you accept. The bill itself is covered in the Power To The Players Act note.

What a small studio can promise at launch

You cannot promise permanence, and you should not try. What you can do is make your promises specific enough that a buyer's expectation matches them — which is what consumer law asks of you anyway, and what makes a later shutdown a planned end rather than a complaint.

  • Say what is being bought. “A licence to use this game on these terms”, not a bare “buy”, and no claim of ownership the terms contradict.
  • Give the online part a lifespan. “Online features are planned to run until at least …”, with what happens if that changes. This is pre-contract information about duration, and it is cheap to write on day one and expensive to add later.
  • Say what survives the servers. Single-player campaign, offline modes, local saves, LAN, a self-hosted server: name the ones you will keep and the ones you will not.
  • Decide the end-of-life path before you need it. A final offline patch, a server binary, or the archive route the Commission mentions with cultural heritage institutions — each is a design decision, cheaper years ahead than at the announcement.
  • Read your termination clause as an authority would. Wide discretion to close the service without clear justification or notice is the example the Commission itself gives under the Unfair Contract Terms Directive.
  • Tell people when you decide, and handle leftover currency. The information duty continues during the contract, and refunds reach currency that can no longer be spent.
This page describes the law and the proposals; it is not legal advice. Where a refund, a term or a delisting decision is contested, the assessment is case-by-case and a lawyer reads the contract, not this page.

What we could not establish

  • Whether the Power To The Players Act exists as a bill. Announced 15 October 2026; no number, no text, no referral and no vote as of 19 October 2026. Outlets disagree on whether it has been introduced. Its content here is reported content, not quoted text.
  • The status of California AB 1921. The Commission records it as under consideration in its June 2026 reply; reporting of July 2026 suggests it stalled, and we could not open that report.
  • How a digital resale market would work anywhere. No text, in any jurisdiction we could read, sets out who runs it or how a transferred entitlement is authenticated.
  • The exact number of validated signatures for the initiative. We use the Commission's own procedural account rather than a press figure; see the Stop Killing Games note for why.
  • Whether any industry body has agreed to discuss the code of conduct. The Commission says it intends to start the exchanges; no commitment from industry is recorded anywhere we could read.

Sources

The EU material is the Commission's Communication, read in the Official Journal. The US material is reporting, and is used only to describe what has been announced.

  1. European Commission — Communication on the European Citizens' Initiative (ECI) ‘Stop Destroying Videogames’ (C/2026/4110 final) Adopted 16 June 2026; Official Journal C/2026/3601 of 9 July 2026. Source for the licence and distribution analysis in §3.1, the “not transferred to consumers at the time of purchase” point, the consumer-law analysis in §3.2 including the quotes on transparency, termination terms and refunds, the costs discussion in §3.3, the code of conduct and end-2026 timetable in §3.4 and §4, the “would not be proportionate” conclusion, and footnote 9 on California AB 2426 and AB 1921. Read in full for this page
  2. Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2024/1824 — registration of the initiative ‘Stop Destroying Videogames’ 19 June 2024. Source for the registration date and decision number, as cited in the Communication
  3. Enduins — US Representative Proposes Video Game Ownership Bill Instead of A “License” 18 October 2026. Secondary. Used for the reported provisions of the Power To The Players Act, the NBA 2K25 example, the Stop Killing Games framing and the reported objections
  4. Pasquale Pillitteri — US lawmaker announces bill to give game buyers ownership, not a license 18 October 2026. Secondary. Used for the announcement date, the absence of a public text, and the statement that the measure is US-only. Its page did not render for us; we use its question-and-answer text, which cites Ars Technica and Engadget
  5. IGN — NBA 2K25 Is Getting Delisted After Just 2 Years, and Single Player Story Mode Will Become Unplayable 5 October 2026. Secondary, quoting 2K's statement. Source for the delisting date, the server shutdown date, and which modes stop and remain. Read in full for this page

Help us keep this straight

If a shutdown, a refund or a delisting has hit your own shop or studio, we want the dates and the wording of the listing — anonymised if you prefer. That is how the next version of this page gets better. A source we can open beats ten pages of commentary, and we correct in public.