KontorBund
The Library

Stop Killing Games: the Commission's 16 June 2026 reply, the voluntary code and what buying a game actually means

Last checked19 October 2026
KeeperOpen — keeper wanted
StatusReply adopted — no legislation

The short version

On 16 June 2026 the European Commission adopted its reply to the citizens' initiative “Stop Destroying Videogames”. It did not propose a law that would force publishers to keep games playable: the Commission considers such an obligation “would not be proportionate”, because publishers' intellectual property rights “must also be respected”. Instead it wants to explore a self-regulatory code of conduct with the industry, and says it will start stakeholder exchanges by the end of 2026. No text exists yet.

So there is still no EU duty to keep a switched-off game running and still no rule that buying means owning. What does apply is consumer law that was already in force: information about functionality and duration before the sale, a ban on omitting the fact that a game is being shut down, fair-terms review, and a refund where the shutdown breaks what the buyer could reasonably expect. In practice the gap is being filled by community server emulators — the most recent, for Need for Speed (2015), published on 17 October 2026.

The initiative, dated

The European citizens' initiative is registered with the Commission as “Stop Destroying Videogames”, not as “Stop Killing Games”. The campaign of that name is the wider movement behind it, and the Commission's reply treats the campaign as the context and the initiative as the legal instrument. Dates below are the Commission's own, from its reply and from the ECI portal.

Registered
19 June 2024, by Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2024/1824, following the organisers' request of 4 May 2024.
What it asks for
That publishers selling or licensing videogames in the EU be required to leave those games “in a functional (playable) state”, and not to disable them remotely “before providing reasonable means to continue functioning”. The initiative says it does not seek ownership, intellectual-property rights or monetisation rights.
Signatures collected
31 July 2024 to 31 July 2025. The Commission's announcement of 16 June 2026 puts the count at “over 1.29 million valid signatures”, with the thresholds reached in 24 Member States. The exact final tally reported elsewhere — 1,294,188 — is not in an official document we could open; see what we could not establish.
Submitted to the Commission
26 January 2026, after the Member States had verified the statements of support. The Commission published the notice confirming the initiative's validity in the ECI register the same day.
Meeting and hearing
The organisers met the Commission on 23 February 2026; the European Parliament held the public hearing on 16 April 2026; the European Economic and Social Committee held its own hearing on 19 May 2026; Parliament debated the initiative in plenary on 21 May 2026.
The Commission's reply
16 June 2026 — Communication C/2026/4110 final, published in the Official Journal as C/2026/3601 of 9 July 2026. It is the 14th citizens' initiative to reach this stage.
One thing the organisers said at the hearing matters for reading the reply. The Commission records that “on these occasions, the organisers stressed that their initiative only targeted games yet to be developed, not those already commercially available”. If you are holding a game that has already been switched off, the initiative was not, on that account, aimed at it — which is part of why the reply's consumer-law section is about refunds and remedies rather than resurrection.

The reply of 16 June 2026

We did not take this on trust from the trade press. The desk's first version of this story came second-hand, from two reports; the reply itself is public, and we read it in the Official Journal. The document is the Communication from the Commission on the European Citizens' Initiative (ECI) ‘Stop Destroying Videogames’, C/2026/4110 final, dated 16 June 2026.

Its structure is worth knowing, because it is where the answer to “can I rely on this?” sits. The Commission sets out the policy and legal context (§2), then responds in three moves: intellectual-property law leaves the distribution conditions to the rights holder (§3.1), consumer law already provides safeguards (§3.2), and a playability requirement might entail costs and risks (§3.3). The conclusion (§4) is one sentence of substance: a proposal for a legal act establishing an obligation to keep games playable “would not be proportionate”.

The reasons given, in the Commission's words: intellectual-property rights “would risk being adversely affected”; an obligation “may also interfere with the protection of confidential business information and know-how”; keeping games playable “can also generate costs for publishers”; and “increased cybersecurity and safety risks may arise for players once publishers cease supporting those games”. The Commission adds a labour-market point in §3.3: 26% of European game developers were laid off in the twelve months of 2024–2025, citing the Big Games Industry Employment Survey 2025.

The reply is the Commission's view, not a ruling. A footnote says the document “reflects the views of the Commission and is without prejudice to the interpretation of Union law by the Court of Justice of the European Union”. There is, as of this page, no Court judgment interpreting the Digital Content Directive at all — the Commission says so itself.

What the reply does and does not commit to

Short list, because the difference between a commitment and a possibility is the whole story here.

Does not
Propose a legal act on playability. Does not create a duty to keep a game running, to hand over server software, or to patch an offline mode. Does not create a “buy = own” rule: §3.1.1 says “the choice of whether and how to distribute or otherwise make available a protected work such as a video game lies with the rights holders within the limits set by the legal framework”.
Does — the code of conduct
“The Commission intends to initiate stakeholder exchanges by the end of 2026 to explore the possibility of elaborating a self-regulatory/industry-led code of conduct to improve the management of video games' end-of-life and strengthen transparency to consumers.” No draft, no signatories, no timetable beyond that start date.
Does — what such a code could contain
§3.4 lists possibilities: “more transparent labelling indicating the possible discontinuation of the game on storefronts”, and “avenues for more partnerships between publishers and cultural heritage institutions to preserve video games”. The Commission says consumer representatives, distributors and hardware manufacturers should be involved.
Does — two reports by the end of 2026
The Commission is reviewing the Digital Content Directive and “plans to present its report by the end of 2026, covering also its application to the discontinuation of digital content and services”. It also says it will work with consumer authorities and organisations on awareness of existing rights.
Reported, not committed
One industry account, cited second-hand in press coverage, put talks with the industry at “by December”. The Commission's own wording is “by the end of 2026”. Where the two differ, the published text governs.

“The voluntary code is law now”

It is not. There is no code: the reply says the Commission intends to explore the possibility of one. A self-regulatory code binds those who sign it, not the sector, and nothing in the reply makes it enforceable by a consumer authority.

“The EU has decided that buying a game means owning it”

It has decided the opposite, or rather declined to decide. The reply says explicitly that a legislative initiative of the kind the initiative requested “is not envisaged”, and it grounds that in copyright and trade-secret protection. A licence describing what you bought is still what you have.

“The Commission said no to everything”

It did not. It points to consumer law that already applies, promises a Digital Content Directive report by the end of 2026, and floats storefront labelling and heritage partnerships in a possible code. If you sell games, those existing duties are the part that can actually reach you.

What EU consumer law does require

The reply's §3.2 is the most useful part for anyone actually selling a game. Its starting point is a negative: “EU consumer protection legislation does not set specific requirements for the duration of the supply of digital content and services, including online video games, nor does it require traders to ensure that consumers can continue using digital content and services once their commercial supply has ended.” Everything after that is duties about information, terms and conformity.

Before the sale — Consumer Rights Directive 2011/83/EU
Clear and comprehensible information about the main characteristics and functionality of the digital content, the duration of the contract, and the conditions for terminating it (Articles 6(1)(o) and 6(1)(r); the reply cites both).
During the relationship — Unfair Commercial Practices Directive 2005/29/EC
No omitting material information (Article 7). The reply's example is direct: “once a provider has decided to discontinue a video game, the UCPD requires them to inform consumers accordingly”, because that affects decisions about in-game purchases.
Your terms — Unfair Contract Terms Directive 93/13/EEC
Terms allowing a provider “with a wide possibility to terminate the service without a sufficiently clear and transparent justification or without a reasonable notice period” may create a significant imbalance and are then not binding on the consumer. The reply calls it a case-by-case assessment.
Conformity — Digital Content Directive (EU) 2019/770
A shutdown “can constitute a lack of conformity with the contract when the trader terminates the supply of the digital content or service sooner than the consumer may reasonably expect” (Articles 7 and 8, Recital 53). Where it does, the consumer requests a refund, proportionate to the period paid for in advance — and that covers in-game purchases terminated along with the main contract, and unused in-game currency (Articles 14 to 16).
Timing of the DCD
It applies only since 1 January 2022. The Commission notes there are so far no Court of Justice rulings interpreting it, and that it is reviewing its application, with a report due by the end of 2026.
One more lever, not for consumers
§2.2 adds competition law: where a dominant publisher or distributor discontinues a gaming service “without an objective justification”, remedies may be sought under Article 102 TFEU before competition authorities and national courts.
What this is not. The reply does not say a shutdown is unlawful, and it does not say a shutdown is fine. It says the answer depends on what you told the buyer, what your terms allow, and what a buyer could reasonably expect about how long the game would run. Nothing on this page is legal advice.

The US: Power To The Players Act

On 15 October 2026 US Representative Ritchie Torres (New York) announced a bill he calls the Power To The Players Act. Press reports describe it as requiring that games be sold as purchases rather than licences and that publishers keep them functional after support ends. We could not open a bill text, a bill number or a congressional record: congress.gov and govtrack.us both refused our requests, and the member's own release was not reachable from here. One headline of 18 October 2026 says the bill was “introduced in Congress”; another, from the same day, says it had not yet been introduced and that no text was public.

Treat it as an announcement, not as law, and not as anything that touches an EU seller. What is already in force in the US is narrower and better sourced: the Commission's own footnote records that a law adopted in 2024 — California Assembly Bill 2426 — “aim[s] to improve transparency in digital markets by requiring traders to clearly inform consumers when digital purchases confer only a license to access content, rather than ownership rights”. The same footnote notes a further California bill, AB 1921 (“Protect our games act”), then under consideration, addressing the discontinuation of video games.

Compare the two routes. California's 2024 law is a labelling duty — tell the buyer it is a licence. The announced federal bill is reported to go further, to ownership and continued functionality. Only the first is law, and it is law in one state.

Since 18 October 2026 the bill has a note of its own — status, the three provisions as reported, the NBA 2K25 example and a watch-list. What follows here is the EU side; nothing in the US proposal changes it.

Community emulation and Article 6

The Commission's reply notices the practice without endorsing it: “It is more often communities that keep games playable by reverse-engineering them or building fan-run private servers.” The newest example is afterhours-2015, published on 17 October 2026: a server emulator for Need for Speed (2015) that lets a legitimately installed copy run against a server on the player's own machine instead of Electronic Arts' infrastructure.

What it is
A Rust workspace of crates implementing the game's server side, plus a PowerShell launcher on Windows that creates a local account, starts the server and routes the game's traffic to it. GitHub describes the repository as a “server emulator for Need for Speed 2015 allowing for custom servers and offline play”.
Licence and form
MPL-2.0, source code only — there is no pre-compiled binary, so using it means installing a Rust toolchain and building it. That is a wall for most players, and the reporting says so.
State of play
The initial release supports a local account, free roam, garage transitions, core tuning and partial save progress; the scripted prologue is unsupported and progression systems are listed as in development. The game's official servers were still running when this was published, with no shutdown announced.
What it is not
Not a legal development, and not authorised by anyone. EA's own “Play Alone” mode still required a live connection; the emulator is a community workaround, not a patch from the publisher.

The open question is the Software Directive, Directive 2009/24/EC, Article 6. It permits decompilation without the right holder's authorisation where reproducing code and translating its form “are indispensable to obtain the information necessary to achieve the interoperability of an independently created computer program with other programs”, and then only if three conditions are met: the acts are done by a licensee or another person entitled to use a copy; the information was not previously readily available to them; and the acts are confined to the parts of the original program necessary for interoperability. Paragraph 2 then forbids using what was learned for other goals, giving it to others except where necessary for interoperability, or using it to develop a program “substantially similar in its expression”.

Nobody in our sources answers this. The Commission's reply deals with intellectual property in general terms — it says exceptions and limitations are “to be interpreted narrowly” — but says nothing about emulators, and its one nod in the other direction is a footnote: “In the specific case of computer programs protected under Directive 2009/24, lawful acquirers have certain user rights which may not be overridden by contract.” Whether a given emulator is inside Article 6, or whether that is even the right provision for observing a network protocol rather than decompiling code, is not established by anything we could read. Do not read the project's existence as a legal clearance.

What a small studio should check

If you sell a game with online features in the EU, the reply changes nothing about your duties — it confirms that the duties you have are the information, terms and conformity ones above. Five things worth checking before your next storefront update:

  • Say what is being bought. A licence, how long the online part is planned to run, and what happens to the single-player part when servers end.
  • Put the lifespan where the buyer sees it. Functionality and duration are pre-contract information under the Consumer Rights Directive, not a support-page footnote.
  • Read your termination clause as a consumer authority would. Wide discretion to end the service with no clear justification or notice period is the example the Commission itself gives under the Unfair Contract Terms Directive.
  • Plan the end-of-life before the shutdown. A final offline patch, a self-hosted server, or the archive route — the reply's §3.4 mentions partnerships with cultural heritage institutions — are cheaper decided years ahead than at the announcement.
  • Tell people when you decide, and handle unused in-game currency. The Unfair Commercial Practices Directive applies during the contract too, and the refund route under the Digital Content Directive covers currency that can no longer be spent.

What we could not establish

  • The exact number of validated signatures. The briefing behind this page gave 1,294,188; the Commission's announcement says “over 1.29 million valid signatures”, and the ECI register would not load its figures for us. We use the Commission's figure.
  • Whether the organisers called the reply a shortfall. The briefing said they did. What we could read is that the campaign's founder called the outcome “not unexpected” and that the campaign said it was “prepared” (Tech Times, 17 October 2026). The campaign's press page is still “coming soon”, so we could not read its own statement and do not quote one.
  • A dated “December” for the code of conduct. The reply says “by the end of 2026”; the December version comes from an industry account cited second-hand in coverage. We treat the Official Journal as the record.
  • Whether the Power To The Players Act has a bill number or text. Reported as introduced on 18 October 2026 by one outlet and as not yet introduced by another. No primary document was reachable.
  • Whether any publisher or trade body has agreed to discuss a code of conduct. The reply says the Commission intends to start the exchanges; nothing in it records a commitment from industry.
  • How community emulators sit with Article 6 of the Software Directive. Discussed above; unresolved in every source we read.

Sources

The Commission's reply is the backbone of this page and we read it in full in the Official Journal, not in the reporting. Where we rely on reporting, we say so, and the two secondary items at the end are marked as such.

  1. European Commission — Communication on the European Citizens' Initiative (ECI) ‘Stop Destroying Videogames’ (C/2026/4110 final) Adopted 16 June 2026; published in the Official Journal as C/2026/3601 of 9 July 2026. Source for the procedural dates, the “over 1.29 million” figure not being in it, the registration decision's citation, the legal analysis in §3.1 and §3.2, the costs and layoff figure in §3.3, the code of conduct and the end-of-2026 timetable in §3.4 and §4, the quotes from the conclusion, and footnote 32 on lawful acquirers. Read in full for this page
  2. European Citizens' Initiative portal — European Commission replies to 'Stop Destroying Videogames' initiative News announcement, 16 June 2026. Source for “over 1.29 million valid signatures” and the thresholds being reached in 24 Member States, and for the reply's date. Read in full for this page
  3. Directive 2009/24/EC on the legal protection of computer programs — Article 6 Source for the decompilation and interoperability conditions quoted in the emulation section, including Article 6(2)(c) on substantially similar programs. Article 6 read in full for this page
  4. GitHub — afterhours-crew/afterhours-2015 The project itself. Source for the repository description, the MPL-2.0 licence and the component structure. Repository created 8 October 2026; the release is dated from the reporting below
  5. Tech Times — NFS 2015 Offline Mode Arrives via Open-Source Emulator as EU Declines to Act 17 October 2026. Secondary. Source for the 17 October release date, the source-only build and toolchain, the tested features, that EA's servers were still running, the MPL-2.0 choice, the 31 March 2024 The Crew shutdown and the campaign's April 2024 launch, and the “not unexpected” / “prepared” characterisation of the reply. Attributed as reporting
  6. Pasquale Pillitteri — US lawmaker announces bill to give game buyers ownership, not a license 18 October 2026. Secondary, and the page did not render for us; used only for the announcement of the Power To The Players Act and its date. Every substantive statement about the bill on this page is flagged as reported

Tell us what we got wrong

If you have the organisers' own statement on the reply, a signature count from the ECI register, a bill number for the Power To The Players Act, or a legal analysis of emulators under Article 6, bring it in. A source we can open beats ten pages of commentary, and we will correct this page in public if it turns out we have something wrong.