KontorBund — Note
The EU Kids ActLast checked 3 November 2026
kontorbund.com/notes/eu-kids-act.html
The EU Kids Act: what the Commission proposed on 17 September 2026 — and the 3 December feedback deadline
The short version
On 17 September 2026 the Commission published a proposal for a
Regulation it calls the EU KIDS Act — COM(2026) 681,
procedure 2026/0286(COD). It would set EU-wide age rules for the
online services children use: seven categories of service in scope, no
account of your own under 13, a guardian-controlled account with a
one-hour daily cap at 13 and 14, an account of your own from 15,
and certified age assurance instead of a date-of-birth box. It
deliberately drops the small-enterprise carve-out the DSA gives its
youth-protection duties. None of this is law. It is a proposal with
Parliament and Council, any of it can change, and the Commission's feedback
window closes on 3 December 2026.
What was proposed
On 17 September 2026 the Commission published a proposal for a
Regulation whose full title is the EU KIDS Act — 'EU Keeping Internet
Digital Spaces Accountable and Trustworthy'. It carries the document
number COM(2026) 681 final, was given the legislative procedure
number 2026/0286(COD), and was submitted to the European
Parliament and the Council. Its legal basis is Article 114 TFEU, the internal
market article — so the argument for acting at EU level is that twenty-seven
national age rules would otherwise fragment the single market.
The Commission describes it as two halves. First, common age rules: who may hold an account on their own. Second, safety by design: how the services themselves have to be built. Alongside that, the proposal reverses the burden of proof for the largest platforms — those with 45 million or more monthly active users in the EU must file a compliance plan and have it checked by independent auditors, at their own expense, before the service reaches children under the new rules.
- Document
COM(2026) 681 final, published 17 September 2026, with the accompanying analysis of impactsSWD(2026) 681 final.- Procedure
2026/0286(COD)— the ordinary legislative procedure. The proposal is with the European Parliament and the Council.- What it would be
- A Regulation: directly applicable in every member state once adopted, with no national transposition. Not binding law today.
- If adopted, when it would apply
- Article 43 says twenty days after publication in the Official Journal it enters into force, and applies from six months later — written as a bracketed placeholder, so even that is not fixed. Article 5 would apply from entry into force; Articles 33 and 35 after twelve months.
- The one date that is real now
- 3 December 2026, midnight Brussels time — the end of the Commission's feedback period on the proposal. The Commission's explainer said 26 November 2026 when this note was first written; its current version says 3 December. See the deadline section.
The seven categories in scope
Article 2(1) of the draft lists the services and systems it would cover — seven of them, and only those that are accessible to minors, a minor meaning anyone under 18 (Article 3):
- (a) Online social networking services
- The definition is taken from the Digital Markets Act (Article 2 of Regulation (EU) 2022/1925).
- (b) Video-sharing platform services
- Defined as in the Digital Markets Act. Along with social networks and app stores, it counts as an online platform for this Regulation (Article 3(2)).
- (c) Software application stores
- App stores. Defined as in the Digital Markets Act, and an online platform for this Regulation.
- (d) Online games
- A video game or a video gaming platform. The definitions are broad enough to reach a great deal, including titles that are not "social" in any obvious sense.
- (e) Operating systems
- Defined as in the Digital Markets Act.
- (f) AI companions
- A system providing sustained, personalised interaction that simulates or facilitates a social or emotional relationship.
- (g) General conversational chatbots
- General-purpose systems able to help across many tasks. Chatbots limited to one specialised job, such as customer service or technical support, are expressly excluded.
The duties are not the same for all seven. App stores, for example, get age-rating duties rather than the account rules; providers of operating systems have essentially one obligation in the draft — if they hold an age signal for a user, they must let that user consent to passing it on to in-scope providers (Article 29(6)) — plus the general anti-circumvention duty in Article 4.
Scope is extraterritorial in the DSA's sense: for the five service categories it attaches to providers offering their service to recipients who are established or located in the Union, not to where the service is accessed from. On a plain reading that follows an EU-based child on holiday outside the EU as well. Providers outside the EU are covered; Article 24 would additionally require a legal representative in a member state.
Article 2(4) then takes a set of things back out of scope, each on the conditions its own limb sets. What that means in practice: a not-for-profit online encyclopaedia, a not-for-profit educational or scientific repository and an open-source software development and sharing platform are out; a small social network, game or app store is not. The exclusions turn on what a service is, not on how small it is.
- What Article 2(4) excludes, on conditions
- Not-for-profit online encyclopaedias (the reference is understood to mean Wikipedia); not-for-profit educational and scientific repositories; services and systems that are primarily educational and run by educational establishments; open-source software-developing and sharing platforms unless the platform is itself an in-scope AI system; services developed and operated solely for scientific research; and systems operated by public authorities for their own use.
- The exclusions are functional, and not final
- Taylor Wessing calls these the draft's "primary exclusions" and stresses that they are functional rather than about size: running a small operation is not on the list, and the Commission may amend it by delegated act. The open-source carve-out is the one that decides most borderline cases — a platform is out of scope only where it does not itself constitute an AI system.
- What that exemption does not do
- It does not exempt a social network because its software is open source. A Mastodon instance is a social network, not a development platform. Likewise, not-for-profit status is a factor in the exemptions above, not a general defence.
- And it does not exempt your size
- Unlike the DSA, there is no general carve-out for small and micro enterprises — only the single monitoring duty for AI companions and chatbots. That is the section most worth reading — it is the point of the proposal, not an oversight.
The three age tiers
The age rules in Article 6 do not apply to everything in scope. They attach to online social networks and video-sharing platforms that show at least one of the risk features the article lists. A single one is enough. The listed features include letting account holders stream live to an indeterminate audience, letting them contact people outside their existing connections, using a recommender system built on profiling, suggesting contacts or content from outside those connections, and designs that encourage uninterrupted consumption or pull the user back with notifications.
- Under 13
- No account of their own. One narrow route remains, and only on video-sharing services designed specifically for young children: a guardian may allow limited access through the guardian's own account, with no account attributed to the child, personalisation and recommender features off, a daily limit of up to one hour, and the guardian able to stop access at any time (Article 7).
- 13 up to 15
- A guardian may set up a limited-features account. The guardian's tools are always on, the guardian can set a daily time limit that may not exceed one hour per day, and the guardian pre-approves new contacts and can cap how many contacts the account has (Article 6(2)). The provider must check that the person opening the account actually holds parental responsibility (Article 26).
- 15 up to 18
- A young person may hold an account of their own without prior parental consent — but the service must by law be safe for them. Protections still run to the eighteenth birthday.
- Existing accounts
- Within six months of the rules applying, providers must establish whether existing account holders are below 15, and disable the accounts of those who are, or whose age cannot be established (Article 6(4), with Article 32). Where a provider can already tell with high confidence that a user is an adult, no new check is required — so most adults would notice nothing.
Age assurance and the EU app
A date-of-birth box would not be enough under this draft — the Commission says self-declared age is explicitly not sufficient. Article 29 requires the providers covered by Article 6 to use an EU age verification solution with an EU proof of age attestation, provided by a third party, certified against the EU Age Verification Scheme and listed by the Commission (Article 30). App stores must also assess the age of the user to keep age-inappropriate apps away from minors (Article 16(4)).
The privacy architecture is unusually explicit for a draft. Article 28 says age assurance "shall not enable the identification of the recipient nor locate, track, target, advertise to or profile recipients", forbids keeping or combining more data than necessary, and says in terms that any age assurance measure shall be zero knowledge proof. The Commission is building the scheme itself as open-source technical requirements for a stand-alone mobile age verification app, and points to the European Digital Identity Wallet as a later route.
- What the service learns
- Whether the user is above or below the age threshold — no name, no date of birth, no identity documents.
- What a member state must provide
- Under Article 31(5), at least one certified EU age verification solution must be available to citizens and residents free of charge. The guardian route is separate: member states must also provide a free, privacy-preserving way to attest parental responsibility (Article 31(1)).
- Who has to use it
- Article 29 binds the certified EU requirement to the providers covered by Article 6 — online social networking services and video-sharing platforms that carry one of the risk features listed there. It does not put certified EU age verification on every service in the seven categories, and not on every game. NeoTeo reads the article the same way: the draft "does not say that every game must collect government-issued identification". Games keep their own duties in Article 15, and app stores theirs in Article 16.
- Where the age check happens
- When a new account is opened. For games, the age question is pushed to the app store — see below.
Safety by design
The larger half of the draft is not about who gets in but about what the service does once they are there. Article 8 sets the general duty; Articles 9 to 12 and 20 specify it. The Commission names the techniques rather than describing them in general terms:
- Addictive design
- For minors, services may not be designed to encourage compulsive or excessive use. The explainer lists what that means: endless autoplay and infinite scrolling without real breaks, notifications designed to pull a child back, rewards for posting or streaming to mass audiences, and streaks that penalise a child for not returning daily.
- Settings, on by default
- Article 11 requires high privacy, safety and security settings for minors by default — geolocation and other tracking off, microphone and camera access off, contact recommendations and contact sync off, and push notifications off and in any case timed to protect sleep hours and school time. A provider may only change those defaults where the minor is above 15.
- Contact and visibility
- Nobody may open direct contact with a minor who has not pre-approved it. Minors do not appear in contact suggestions, cannot be added to groups without explicit agreement, and can block anyone without their identity being disclosed (Article 12(1)). By default only people the minor has accepted can see their account or content, and people without an account cannot access a minor's content at all (Article 12(3)). Others must not be able to download or capture a minor's content.
- Feeds
- Recommender systems must be optimised for safety, quality and mental health rather than engagement; recommendation based on engagement signals is off by default, and minors must be able to choose at least one recommender option that is not based on profiling (Article 10).
- AI companions and chatbots
- Article 14 forbids designs that simulate relationships in ways likely to create emotional dependency, bars carrying a child's earlier conversations into later ones by default, and requires testing before launch and monitoring afterwards. Built into a platform or a game, a companion or chatbot may not switch on automatically, may not be pushed at children, and must be easy to turn off.
- Guardian tools
- Article 20 requires effective guardian tools on every service in scope — screen time, seeing and approving contacts, managing settings, and reporting harmful content on the child's behalf. On the 13-and-14 accounts they are always on. The tools complement the provider's own duties; they do not replace them.
No small-business exemption
This is the part of the proposal that matters most to small operators, and it is not an accident. The explanatory memorandum says it in one sentence:
In the Commission's own words
"At the same time, small and micro enterprises are not exempted from this Regulation, since they may equally provide harms to minors. It would undermine the objective of this proposal to exclude them from scope."
That is a deliberate departure from the DSA, which keeps micro and small enterprises out of its youth-protection duties. The Commission's memo acknowledges that many small providers "were previously not subject to Article 28 of the Digital Services Act".
- What a size test would have done
- Nothing here turns on turnover, headcount or user numbers for the core duties. A five-person game studio and a platform with a hundred million users read the same obligation.
- Not exempt as a class — one carve-out
- Micro and small enterprises are not generally exempt from the Regulation. The one relief Article 14 gives them is that the post-market monitoring duty for AI companions and general conversational chatbots does not apply to micro and small enterprises; every other duty reaches them as it reaches a large platform. It is the only such exemption we found in the operative text.
- Where size does still matter
- The compliance-plan and audit regime applies to very large online platforms — 45 million or more monthly active users in the EU. The Commission notes those duties should in principle not touch SMEs, whose user base does not reach that scale.
- Enforcement
- For online platforms the draft builds on the DSA's enforcement machinery; for AI companions and chatbots on the AI Act; for video games that are not online platforms, on national authorities designated by member states. Fines can reach 6% of total worldwide annual turnover. National authorities take the smaller providers and the Commission the largest, with an expedited procedure for Commission-supervised services — see who would enforce it.
What it would mean for games
Online games are one of the seven categories, defined as a video game or a video gaming platform. Their obligations come mainly through Article 15 and the app-store rules in Article 16.
- Safety by design, applied to a game
- Providers must ensure compulsive or excessive use is not encouraged, apply high-privacy default settings, put contact safeguards in place between minors and other players, and give guardian tools — with access by under-13s only enabled and controlled through those guardian tools.
- Per-game age ratings, enforced at the store
- Article 16 requires every app store to run an age-rating system covering each software application it offers, to refuse minors access to or purchase of applications inappropriate for their age, and to assess the user's age in order to do so. In practice the age recommendation for a game is checked by the store before the download, not inside the game after it.
- The store's own age-assurance duty
- It is a separate duty from Article 29, and a different method. Arthur Cox reads Article 16 as requiring a store to assess its users' age, and — unless it can establish with a high degree of confidence that the user is over 18 — to do so by an age-assurance method such as biometric age estimation. App stores are not obliged to use the certified EU age verification solution, though they may offer it. That is a reading of the draft by a law firm, not a mechanism in force.
- Monetisation
- The standalone rules on economic transactions in the draft apply to social networks and video-sharing platforms, not to games. Monetisation practices in games are left to codes of conduct, which Article 17 also uses for age rating.
- What the industry says
- Video Games Europe cautioned against "sweeping age assurance measures applicable to every game and player in Europe". We quote the trade body's criticism as it was reported; it is not our characterisation of the draft.
One thing the draft does not change: consumer law in this area is already being enforced. On 30 September 2026 the CPC Network opened coordinated actions against nine games companies over nine games — ten companies and eleven games once the parallel action against Activision Blizzard UK is counted — under its non-binding Key Principles of 21 March 2025. See the CPC action on in-game currencies for the checklist authorities are already applying.
The definition is wider than "online game" sounds
The draft's definitions of video game and video gaming platform are broad enough to reach far beyond always-online titles — including, on a commentator's reading, games with a classic online multiplayer mode, and older titles that still have a server. Nothing in the text we have read limits the duties by release date or by the size of the player base, and there is no grandfathering clause. That is a reading of draft wording, not a settled outcome, and it is exactly the sort of thing the parliamentary process could change.
What it would mean for small servers
The Fediverse — the network of independent servers running software such as Mastodon — is where the removal of the size exemption bites hardest in practice, and the criticism is concrete.
The Austrian digital rights organisation epicenter.works published its analysis on 22 September 2026, under a heading of "Bye Bye Fediverse". Its argument: billion-euro corporations such as Meta, Google and Apple face the same requirements as small European providers; Wikipedia and Codeberg get their exemption, a decentralised network such as Mastodon does not. That means age verification for every single instance and every software marketplace, with all the administrative weight attached — infrastructure a server with a few hundred users cannot afford, while a Meta or TikTok pays it from petty cash. Their conclusion is blunt: the smaller operators either shut down or throw young people out of the open, privacy-friendly parts of the internet.
There is a genuine technical conflict behind that, not just a political one.
Article 12(3) requires that recipients without an account must not be
able to access a minor's content, and that by default only previously accepted
users can. In ActivityPub, the protocol under most of the Fediverse, a post
addressed to the special Public recipient must be accessible
without authentication — that is what the W3C recommendation says. A minor's
account could therefore not address posts to Public. Because the
protective defaults apply to every account that has not been established as an
adult, that would reach beyond minors until the age check has happened.
- Who owes the duty
- The operator of the instance, not the Mastodon project or the people who wrote the software.
- Whether an exemption applies
- Open-source development and sharing platforms are exempted; a social network running open-source software is not. This is the point on which epicenter.works' criticism rests and it follows from Article 2(4)(d).
- What federation cannot fix
- An origin server controls what it delivers and to whom, not what a remote server does with it afterwards. A screenshot cannot be unfederated. On a central platform the operator enforces its rules across the whole service; in a federated network it enforces them on its own server.
- Where the criticism goes further than the text
- The claim that every private instance will have to check ages does not follow automatically. Whether a private, non-commercial hobby server is even a covered social network depends on how the EU-law notion of an "information society service" — services normally provided for remuneration — applies to it. That is an open legal question, not a settled one, and the restricted account for 13-and-14-year-olds is something a provider may offer, not something it must.
The same question has been raised about private game servers, and the draft answers it no more clearly: on NeoTeo's reading of 21 October 2026 the text contains no express ban on them and does not settle how its duties apply to every hosting arrangement, while the campaign Stop Killing Games argues that the proposal could harm private servers and game preservation — the campaign's criticism as that report relays it, and a reading of draft wording, not a settled outcome.
How it fits with the DSA
The KIDS Act does not replace the Digital Services Act. The Commission's memorandum describes it as putting into hard law specifications it had already published as guidelines on the protection of minors under Regulation (EU) 2022/2065, and as particularising the Article 28 DSA duty to keep minors safe where that concerns safety by design and age assurance. The point of legislating, in the Commission's framing, is that guidelines are not enforceable in the same way.
- Who supervises what
- Social networks, video-sharing platforms and app stores are classed as online platforms for this purpose, and a video gaming platform too. Their KIDS Act obligations are supervised and enforced through the DSA machinery rather than a new regime. AI companions and chatbots fall under the AI Act. Video games that are not online platforms fall to national authorities.
- What large platforms gain
- An expanded set of duties: a compliance plan, independent audit, corrective action the Commission can order, enhanced age-verification requirements and interoperability of guardian controls.
- The age-verification app
- The EU age verification solution in Article 29 is the same technical scheme the Commission has been building separately — open-source requirements for a stand-alone app, with each member state obliged to make at least one certified solution available free of charge.
- What compliance would buy you
- Providers of online social networking services, video-sharing platform services and video gaming platforms that comply with the Kids Act "can hope to be deemed in compliance with Article 28(1) DSA" for the matters the Act covers — that is Taylor Wessing's reading of the deemed-compliance rule. In effect one rule set, read twice, rather than two parallel duties.
- The wider package
- The Act is one part of a child safety package that also includes a Digital Fairness Act and revisions to the Consumer Protection Cooperation Regulation and the Audiovisual Media Services Directive.
The 29 October 2026 standstill on national laws
At the daily press briefing on 29 October 2026 the Commission put the national drafts on hold. Digital spokesman Thomas Regnier said the executive had decided to "postpone for 12 months any draft national laws overlapping with the future harmonised rules", and gave the reason the whole proposal rests on: different age limits in different member states would fragment the single market and leave platforms unable to comply. He declined to list the countries affected and cited one by way of example — Austria, whose plan to bar social media for under-14s was sent to Brussels for review in July 2026.
Four days later Denmark showed what the pause means in practice. On 2 November 2026 the government said it would ask the Commission to let it set a national minimum age of 15 for social media while the EU negotiations continue. The move followed Politiken's report that the Commission will not approve new national laws restricting access to social platforms for 12 months, as The Copenhagen Post relayed it on the same day.
- What was decided
- A 12-month postponement of any draft national law overlapping with the future harmonised rules, announced at the daily briefing. Reported, not published: Politiken (relayed by The Copenhagen Post) and Digital Watch Observatory both report it as the Commission's position, and we have found no decision, letter, press release or other instrument from the Commission itself.
- Denmark asks anyway
- On 2 November 2026 Denmark's government said it would ask the Commission to allow a minimum age of 15 for social media while the common rules are negotiated. The governing parties agreed the limit with Venstre and the Conservative People's Party; a bill is to be presented at the beginning of 2027 and take effect that July, with 1 July 2027 the date the plan was due to take effect. The Copenhagen Post reports that the Commission's position could delay that date.
- Egelund's answer
- Minister for Digitalisation Christina Egelund (Moderates) told the Danish news agency Ritzau, in a written response, that she was "disappointed and bewildered" and that "it is not reasonable that the Commission creates a vacuum where the protection of children and young people is lower than it could have been". She said she was prepared to withdraw the Danish law once common EU rules took effect, and that Denmark had already waited a year "since 25 member states called on the Commission to act in the Jutland Declaration during the Danish EU presidency". The report gives no date for that declaration, and Egelund did not say whether the government still expected the limit to start on 1 July 2027.
- Another three years, an MEP warns
- Christel Schaldemose (Social Democrats), the European Parliament's chief negotiator on the DSA, told Politiken the Commission's position could mean the Danish limit cannot be introduced for another three years. That is her expectation, not a date in any text.
- Austria
- The example Regnier cited: an under-14 ban, sent for review in July 2026. Austrian state secretary for digitalisation Alexander Pröll told POLITICO that it was unacceptable for Brussels to block national legislation without first putting forward a comprehensive European solution of its own.
- Austria has been told to delay
- Digital Watch Observatory reported on 2 November 2026 that the Commission has told Austria to delay its under-14 draft for 12 months because it overlaps with the proposed EU framework — the example Regnier gave, now reported as an instruction to Vienna. That outlet adds that Austria had anticipated the Commission could require its proposal to be put on hold.
- Belgium and Portugal
- Also caught, according to Agence Europe as the reports relay it — second-hand, because the Commission itself declined to name the member states.
- Greece is not
- Exempt, because the Commission's review of its law ended before the EU proposal was tabled. Its ban on social media for under-15s is due to take effect on 1 January 2027 — see our note on the Greek act.
- Italy and France
- Both notified well before September and are expected to be allowed to proceed, according to dpa. AFP reported that the Commission had nonetheless asked Paris to rework its text. That does not make a French age limit real: the ban on social media for under-15s adopted in July 2026 was struck down by the Conseil constitutionnel on 14 August 2026 (our note).
- France and Greece are not caught — and Italy is open
- The pause does not apply automatically to every national measure, Digital Watch Observatory reports: France and Greece advanced their proposals before the EU Kids Act was tabled, while the Commission is still considering measures from other countries, including Italy. That agrees with what we had on Greece from the 29–30 October reports. On Italy it sits awkwardly beside dpa's report that Italy and France were expected to proceed: the two accounts differ, and we have no Commission document either way.
- 18 months, if the Council moves
- The standstill could be extended by a further six months if the Council adopts its first-reading position in the meantime, Agence Europe reported.
- What it follows from
- Not a new position. On 4 February 2026, after Spain announced plans for an under-16 ban, Regnier warned that imposing extra obligations on platforms was off limits because the DSA already regulates the matter.
- What has not changed
- The EU Kids Act is still a proposal with Parliament and Council, the feedback window still closes on 3 December 2026, and no national rule we describe on this page has been repealed. Ireland, which holds the Council presidency, has said it wants to speed work on the file up.
Who would enforce it, and when it could apply
Enforcement is not a new agency. The draft builds on machinery that already exists: national authorities supervise the smaller providers, and the Commission takes on the largest ones itself. The details below come from three law-firm analyses of the proposal — Taylor Wessing's of 5 October 2026, Greenberg Traurig's of 19 October 2026 and Arthur Cox's of 21 October 2026 — and from the Commission's own explainer, with each point attributed where they differ. These are readings of the draft, not a settled outcome.
- Who supervises whom
- National authorities supervise the smaller providers; the Commission takes on the largest. AI companions and chatbots run through the AI Act, and video games that are not online platforms through the national authorities member states designate.
- The expedited procedure
- For services and systems under Commission supervision, the Commission aims to issue preliminary findings within 30 working days and a final decision within 90 working days. The Commission's own explainer puts the same thing at "preliminary findings within 30 days and a final decision targeted within 90 days", without saying working days — so treat the working-days framing as the reading of Taylor Wessing and Arthur Cox. Arthur Cox states it the same way on 21 October 2026: preliminary findings within 30 working days, a final decision within 90.
- The supervisory fee
- A top-up to the DSA supervisory fee, charged only to providers under Commission supervision, capped at 0.03% of worldwide annual net income in the preceding financial year. It is a fee that covers supervision costs, not a penalty, and providers supervised by national authorities do not pay it.
- The fines
- Up to 6% of worldwide annual turnover. Greenberg Traurig reads the draft as setting that ceiling for infringements by AI companion and chatbot providers, with the other services left to the DSA sanction regime; the Commission's explainer states the 6% ceiling without drawing that line, and Arthur Cox reads the text the same way. Data protection authorities keep their own powers under the GDPR over the age-assurance data.
- When it would apply
- Once adopted, generally about six months after publication in the Official Journal, with certain aspects applying earlier or later. Taylor Wessing expects a faster-than-usual passage given the political pressure, and puts the most optimistic — or pessimistic — scenario at Q1 2028. Arthur Cox puts it more plainly: if the proposal is adopted, the legislation is "unlikely to become applicable before 2028". Both are expectations, not dates in the text.
- The review
- The Commission's review of the Regulation is currently anticipated by 31 August 2030 — Greenberg Traurig's reading of the draft's review clause, and a date in a text Parliament and Council can still move.
National positions: Germany, Ireland and the Netherlands
Germany is one of the member states that is not waiting. On 14 October 2026 the Bundeskabinett adopted a key-points paper (Eckpunktepapier) on child and youth protection in the digital world, built on the 56 recommendations of its own expert commission. It sets out both what Berlin will argue for in these negotiations and the national rule it intends to put in place in the meantime.
- What Berlin will press for in the talks
- A minimum age of 13; an ambitious "Safety by Design" approach including a ban on addictive design in product design, so that harmful services never reach the market; algorithmic recommendation systems disabled by default, as an opt-in solution; and carrying the main requirements of the Commission's DSA Article 28(4) guidelines on the protection of minors into the EU Kids Act.
- Where the fines should go
- Germany also wants fines the Commission imposes for breaches of youth media protection to be channelled into media-education measures, so the money reaches children directly.
- The national interim framework
- While the EU has no minimum age, an amendment of the German Jugendschutzgesetz would bar under-13s from using social networks in principle — only demonstrably child-appropriate services exempt — with graduated restrictions for 13- to 18-year-olds. From 2027 the German implementation of the EUDI wallet, d-you, is to offer voluntary age confirmation that can prove a minimum age without transmitting further personal data. None of it is in force; the paper is a plan and needs implementing legislation.
- Why it matters to this file
- A national under-13 rule in the largest member state is precisely the fragmentation Article 114 is invoked to prevent — and it also tells you what one government will argue for when the Council position is drafted. The full treatment, with the eight non-legislative measures and the SGB VIII and BGB changes, is in our note on the paper.
- Ireland's position
- In Ireland the two ministers who hold this file, the Minister for Arts, Culture, Communications, Media and Sport, Patrick O'Donovan, and Tánaiste Simon Harris, have both indicated support for restricting minors' social media — according to a student comment piece in the University Observer (15 October 2026), which names no instrument, date or government decision. We have found no official Irish statement to match it, so treat this as reported, not as a national plan.
- The Netherlands' position — set out 30 October 2026
- On 30 October 2026 the Dutch government published the cabinet's (kabinet) position in its own news item: the cabinet is positive about the Commission's proposal, including an EU-wide minimum age of 15 for creating an account on social media and video platforms independently, with limited "mini-accounts" under parental supervision for 13- and 14-year-olds, and the safety-by-design duties, which reach AI chatbots, social media, video platforms, online games and app stores. Dutch outlets carried it from 31 October 2026 on. That matches the draft's tiers above; the government's own text puts the mini-accounts at children "between 13 and 15", as the draft does. The cabinet gives common European rules as the reason: children are better protected across the Union, and a patchwork of national rules is avoided. This is a member state's position on a file in the legislative process, not a duty on anyone.
- Where the duty would sit — with the platforms
- The cabinet supports the proposal's premise that companies are themselves responsible for making their services safe for children: safety by design meaning no addictive techniques and stricter privacy requirements. It backs the rule that very large online platforms must demonstrate to the European Commission that they meet those requirements, and the principle that the responsibility thereby sits with the platforms themselves.
- The age check itself — safe, reliable, possibly the EDI wallet
- Checking someone's age has to happen in a safe and reliable way, the cabinet says, and age verification via the European Digital Identity (EDI) wallets can be one of the possibilities for it. The government's text names the wallet as one option among several, not as the mechanism the Act would prescribe.
- Before adoption: research first, and no permanent age limit
- The cabinet wants the effects of a minimum age and of age verification on privacy and fundamental rights — of children and of adults — properly examined before the Act is adopted. It also says an age limit is "not a goal in itself": if social media and video platforms become safe enough, the Commission should reassess whether the limit is still needed. The cabinet adds that a minimum age can have consequences for freedom of expression and access to information, and asks for extra attention to that during the European legislative procedure.
- Parental responsibility, and parents with unequal capacity
- This is where the draft's guardian layer meets the cabinet's concerns. The draft has the provider check that whoever opens a 13- or 14-year-old's account actually holds parental responsibility (Article 26) and give guardians the managing tools. The cabinet warns that mandatory verification of parental responsibility risks platforms collecting more personal data on parents and children than necessary, and that handing screen-time management and oversight of contacts to parents can put too much responsibility on them: not every parent has the same capacity to supervise, which can lead to unequal access for children.
- The earlier Dutch non-paper — and the EDI wallet caveat
- Before this, the cabinet had set out its line in a Non-paper Europese minimumleeftijd sociale media: age verification should be privacy-friendly and establish only whether someone has reached the age threshold, without processing other personal data. The cabinet names the European Digital Identity (EDI) wallet as one possible route for this — and says whether the approach chosen protects privacy sufficiently still has to be examined. We have read the non-paper through this reporting, not in the original.
- What the criticism says — Bits of Freedom
- The Dutch digital rights organisation Bits of Freedom says the proposal puts privacy, freedom of expression and accessibility under pressure. Children have the same right to free expression and access to information as adults; people without an identity document or an official registration must not be shut out because formal age verification is required; and a check that keeps children out means other users must prove their age too. Parental supervision adds a further check on top, since a parent has to be able to show that a child is really theirs. That is the reporting's account of their position; we have not read a statement from Bits of Freedom itself.
- What happens next
- State secretary Aerdts — the government's own release gives the portfolio as Digitale Economie en Soevereiniteit — intends to discuss these points with European colleagues in the coming period. The news item carries no document number and names no date on which the cabinet adopted the position, so treat 30 October 2026 as the date of publication, not as the date of a formal decision we have seen; we have read that news item, not the cabinet's position paper or letter behind it. Nor do we rely on the party labels in the press reporting, which are inconsistent between the outlets.
What we could not establish
We would rather say what we could not check than write around it.
- A campaign quote we are not repeating
- Several reports say the gaming-preservation campaign Stop Killing Games warned that the Act could "implode the whole video games industry". We could not open the original coverage or the campaign's own statement — the pages refused our requests and their press page is not published — so we do not quote it here. If you have the primary statement, send it and we will add it.
- Whether a private hobby server is in scope
- This turns on the meaning of an "information society service" and on facts about the individual server. No official answer exists yet, and we are not going to invent one.
- Whether open-source operating systems are covered
- The operating-system definition comes from the Digital Markets Act; whether free and open-source distributions fall inside it is not settled by the draft's text. Outside the EU that same question has already been answered in law, in opposite directions: see Age checks move into the operating system and the explainer Age verification and age assurance.
- What it will cost
- Nobody has a defensible number. The Commission's own analysis says the costs cannot be conclusively determined, especially for the many small providers involved, and works with a range of a few hundred to a few thousand euros for a ready-made age check.
- What the final text will say
- Everything above is the Commission's proposal as published. Parliament and Council amend; this file could look very different in a year.
The 3 December deadline
The Commission is collecting feedback on the proposal until 3 December 2026, midnight Brussels time. Its own explainer says the aim is to hear from children, parents, guardians, teachers and educators, as well as from the online platforms the proposal would cover. The Commission says the responses will be summarised and presented to the European Parliament and the Council to feed the legislative debate — which is why the window matters even though the file is already with the co-legislators.
This page said 26 November 2026 until 21 October 2026. That was the date in the Commission's explainer when we first read it. The current version of the same page — marked last updated 8 October 2026 — says 3 December 2026, and Arthur Cox's briefing of 21 October 2026 puts the close on the same day. We could not open the Have Your Say entry for this proposal itself, because that page renders through a script, so the date above rests on the Commission's own explainer. If the consultation entry says something else, the consultation entry wins — tell us and we correct this again.
- What it is not
- It is not a vote and it does not change the text by itself. It is evidence put on the record while Parliament and Council are still forming positions.
- What is useful in a response
- The Commission has to justify the impact. A concrete number — what an age check, an age-rating system or a compliance plan would cost your business, with the work it implies — is harder to argue with than a position. That is the same kind of figure our Observatory collects.
- If you miss it
- The legislative process continues without you. National and industry consultations, and the Parliament's own committee work, are the later doors — and they open less predictably.
Do not treat any of this as settled
Nothing in this note is legal advice, and nothing in it is a duty you owe today. The age tiers, the seven categories, the missing size exemption, the app-store enforcement and the application date are all draft. Plan what you can control — the design choices you would have to change, the age data you would have to handle — and read the text again when the Council position is published.
Sources
The proposal text, the Commission's press release and the Commission's own explainer are the backbone; everything interpretive is attributed to whoever said it. Where a source is secondary, we say so. We have read the proposal, the press release and the explainer for this page.
-
COM(2026) 681 final — Proposal for the EU KIDS Act (EUR-Lex) The authentic draft, 17 September 2026. Source for the scope in Article 2, the age tiers in Article 6, the safeguards in Articles 8–12, games and app stores in Articles 15–17, age assurance in Articles 28–32, the application date in Article 43 and the explanatory memorandum. Read in full for this page
-
European Commission — EU KIDS Act to restrict social media platforms' access to children in the EU The press release, 17 September 2026. Source for the publication date and for the reversal of the burden of proof
-
European Commission — The KIDS Act explained The Commission's own FAQ, current version last updated 8 October 2026 and re-read on 21 October 2026. Source for the 3 December 2026 feedback deadline — the same page said 26 November 2026 when we first read it — the free EU age verification app, the named addictive-design techniques, the six-month check on existing accounts, and the 6% fine ceiling
-
European Commission — Proposal for EU KIDS Act and supporting documents The document library: the proposal, the analysis of impacts and the factsheet
-
Pinsent Masons — The scope of the proposed KIDS Act Secondary, legal analysis, 2 October 2026. Source for the seven-category list as a list, the exemptions, the operating-system duty, the DSA classification, and the Video Games Europe quotation
-
heise online — Age verification in the Fediverse: How the KIDS Act challenges Mastodon Secondary, technical analysis, 2 October 2026. Source for the ActivityPub conflict with Article 12, the verdict on the "every instance" claim, the cost estimate in the analysis of impacts and the role of the operator
-
epicenter.works — Zwei Fronten, ein Irrweg (German) The Austrian digital rights organisation's own analysis, 22 September 2026. Source for the criticism attributed to them — "age verification for every single instance", the Wikipedia and Codeberg comparison and the "Bye Bye Fediverse" argument
-
Hunton Andrews Kurth via National Law Review — European Commission Unveils Proposal for EU KIDS Act Secondary, 2 October 2026. Cross-check of the three age tiers and the app-store enforcement of game age recommendations
-
Taylor Wessing — EU KIDS Act: Age checks and design duties Secondary, legal analysis, 5 October 2026. Source for the supervisory split between national authorities and the Commission, the expedited procedure counted in working days, the 0.03% cap on the supervisory-fee top-up, the functional exclusions and the delegated-act power to change them, the DSA Article 28(1) deemed-compliance rule, the national draft laws notified by France, Italy, Austria, Norway, Poland and Belgium, and the expectation of general application about six months after publication in the Official Journal, possibly as early as Q1 2028 — the timing is the firm's expectation, not a legislative date
-
Greenberg Traurig — EU KIDS Act: Proposed EU Rules for Online Platforms, Age Verification, and AI Chatbots Secondary, legal analysis (GT Alert), 19 October 2026, added 20 October 2026. Source for the exclusions in Article 2(4) read as conditional, the "not generally exempt" reading of the size question alongside the one monitoring carve-out for AI chatbots, the split on fines — up to 6% of worldwide annual turnover for AI companions and chatbots, the DSA sanction regime for the other services — the supervisory fee as a fee and not a penalty, the anticipated review date of 31 August 2030, and the timetable of general application six months after the effective date. Read in full 20 October 2026
-
Arthur Cox — EU Kids Act: New proposal to protect kids online Secondary, legal briefing, 21 October 2026, added 21 October 2026. Source for the consultation close on 3 December 2026, the exclusions list as a list, the six-month clean-up of existing accounts, the app-store duty to assess users' age by an age-assurance method such as biometric age estimation unless it can establish with high confidence that the user is over 18, the 6% ceiling for AI companions and chatbots, the 30/90 working-day fast track, and the expectation that the rules are unlikely to apply before 2028. Read in full 21 October 2026
-
NeoTeo — EU KIDS Act proposal: gaming rules and age checks Secondary, technology report, 21 October 2026, added 21 October 2026. Source for reading Article 29 as tying certified EU age verification to the Article 6 services rather than to every game, for the point that the draft contains no express ban on private servers and does not settle every hosting arrangement, for the six-month application period in Article 43, and for the Stop Killing Games criticism as that report relays it. We read the English edition; the same piece runs in the outlet's Spanish, German, French, Italian, Dutch, Polish and Portuguese editions
-
NoobFeed — EU Kids Act Could Put New Regulatory Costs on European Games Opinion piece, 3 October 2026. Listed only because we correct it: it calls the text "leaked" and reports an unattributed cost figure that we do not repeat
-
PubAffairs Bruxelles — Commission seeks feedback on EU KIDS Act Carries the Commission's own news item on the feedback period, including that responses will be summarised and presented to Parliament and Council. Secondary reproduction of a Commission text
-
European Commission — Consumer protection authorities ramp up action to protect gamers' rights (
IP/26/2018) Press release, 30 September 2026, added 13 October 2026 for the paragraph on games: the coordinated actions against nine games companies, the parallel Activision Blizzard UK action over Diablo Immortal and Call of Duty Mobile, and the Key Principles of 21 March 2025. Full treatment in the CPC action note -
BMBFSFJ — Bundesregierung beschließt Eckpunkte für besseren Kinder- und Jugendmedienschutz (German) Press release, 14 October 2026, added 14 October 2026 for Germany's position: the Cabinet's adoption that day, and Germany's asks in the EU Kids Act talks. The key-points paper itself is the source for the minimum age, the ban on addictive design, the opt-in for recommendation systems and the use of EU fines for media education. Both read in full 14 October 2026
-
University Observer — Following in Australia's Footsteps? The EU Kids Act (comment) Student comment piece, 15 October 2026, added 16 October 2026 for Ireland's position. The only report we have that the Minister for Arts, Culture, Communications, Media and Sport, Patrick O'Donovan, and Tánaiste Simon Harris have shown support for such a ban — the piece's own phrase — with nothing official from the Irish government behind it. Secondary and unattributed: the piece names no instrument, date or government decision, it does not say where the proposal stands procedurally, and we found no official Irish statement. Everything else in it that we repeat — the age tiers, the scope, the 6% fine and the consultation deadline — we take from the Commission documents above, not from here. Read in full 16 October 2026
-
Brussels Signal — Brussels freezes national social media bans for children Secondary report, 30 October 2026, added 30 October 2026 for the standstill section. Source for the decision announced at the daily press briefing the day before, Regnier's wording — "postpone for 12 months any draft national laws overlapping with the future harmonised rules" — the single-market reason, Austria's under-14 plan sent for review in July, his refusal to list the countries, Belgium and Portugal as caught according to Agence Europe, Greece's exemption and its 1 January 2027 date, Italy and France expected to proceed according to dpa, AFP on Paris being asked to rework its text, the possible further six months if the Council adopts its first-reading position, Pröll's reaction to POLITICO, Ireland's presidency wanting to speed the file up, and the 4 February 2026 warning to Spain over its under-16 plans. Read in full 30 October 2026. POLITICO, Anadolu Ajansı and other outlets ran the same story on 29 October 2026; we saw those as headlines only. We found no Commission press release, transcript or procedure document recording the decision, so nothing here is attributed to an EU text
-
The Copenhagen Post (Ritzau) — Denmark seeks EU approval to introduce social media age limit of 15 Secondary report, 2 November 2026, added 2 November 2026 for the standstill section. Source for Denmark's request to the Commission, the agreement on a limit of 15 with Venstre and the Conservative People's Party, the bill at the beginning of 2027 and the effect date of 1 July 2027, Egelund's written reply to Ritzau — "disappointed and bewildered", the "vacuum" sentence, the undertaking to withdraw the law once common EU rules take effect, the Jutland Declaration and its 25 member states — Schaldemose's three-year warning to Politiken, and the fact that Egelund did not say whether the government still expects 1 July 2027. This is Ritzau's account of what Politiken reported; we did not open the Politiken piece itself. Read in full 2 November 2026
-
Digital Watch Observatory — European Commission wants a postponement of overlapping national social media laws for children Secondary report, 2 November 2026, added 2 November 2026 for the standstill section. Source for reading the 12-month postponement as a decision of the Commission, for the Commission having told Austria to delay its under-14 draft, for Austria having anticipated that, for the pause not applying automatically to every national measure, for France and Greece having advanced their proposals before the EU Kids Act was tabled, for Italy still being under consideration, and for its summary of the Act's three age tiers and safety-by-design duties. It names no instrument either. Read in full 2 November 2026
-
Rijksoverheid — Kabinet steunt EU Kids Act, maar uit zorgen over privacy en grondrechten (Dutch) The Dutch government's own news item, 30 October 2026, from the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Climate Policy, added 3 November 2026. The fullest primary account of the Netherlands' position that we have: the cabinet's positive stance and its preference for common European rules over a patchwork, the 15-year floor for independently creating accounts, the safety-by-design duties reaching social media, video platforms, AI chatbots, online games and app stores, the support for platform responsibility with very large online platforms demonstrating compliance to the Commission, the request that age checks be safe and reliable with EDI wallets as one possibility, the freedom of expression and access to information caveat, the "not a goal in itself" sentence and the reassessment ask, the mini-accounts for children "between 13 and 15" and the burden this puts on parents, and the privacy risk in mandatory verification of parental responsibility. It is a news item about the cabinet's position, not the position paper or letter itself, and it carries no document number. Read in full 3 November 2026
-
Dutch IT Channel — Kabinet steunt Europese kinderwet online, maar heeft zorgen (Dutch) Secondary report, 31 October 2026, added 3 November 2026 for the Netherlands' position. It follows the government's news item closely: the 15-year floor, the common European rules and the patchwork argument, the support for platform responsibility with very large platforms accounting to the Commission, the EDI wallets as one possible route for the age check, the fundamental-rights caveat and the reassessment ask, and the concerns about parental burden, inequality between children and the verification of parental responsibility. It puts the mini-accounts at "13 to 15", as the government's text does. Its piece uses "hij" for Aerdts where the government's own release quotes her in the first person, so we do not follow the pronoun
-
iBestuur — Kabinet steunt EU Kids Act (Dutch) Secondary report, 2 November 2026, added 2 November 2026 for the Netherlands' position: the cabinet's positive stance on the proposal and its preference for common European rules, the 15-year line with limited "mini-accounts" under parental supervision for 13- and 14-year-olds, the wish that platforms not collect unnecessary personal data on parents and children, the "not a goal in itself" sentence and the reassessment ask, the earlier Non-paper Europese minimumleeftijd sociale media with the privacy-friendly verification line, the EDI wallet as one option and the finding that privacy protection still needs examination, the safety-by-design list, the 45-million threshold, and Bits of Freedom's criticism. Read in full 2 November 2026
-
Rockingrobots — Kabinet steunt EU Kids Act met strengere regels voor AI-chatbots en sociale media (Dutch) Secondary report, 2 November 2026, added 2 November 2026 for the Netherlands' position. Source for the cabinet's support for the 15-year floor for independently creating accounts, for the consequences of a minimum age for freedom of expression and access to information being among the points it wants examined, for the parental-capacity point and the unequal access it could produce, for the mandatory verification of parental responsibility as a data-protection risk, and for Aerdts (Digitale Economie en Soevereiniteit) intending to raise the points with European colleagues. It puts the mini-accounts at "13 to 15", as the government's own text does — the section's "13- and 14-year-olds" is the draft's band, 13 up to 15, on which iBestuur says 13 and 14. Read in full 2 November 2026
-
Telecompaper — Kabinet wil onderzoek naar gevolgen EU Kids Act voor privacy en grondrechten (Dutch) Secondary report, 2 November 2026, added 2 November 2026. Source for the cabinet's view that the consequences of a minimum age and of age verification for the fundamental rights and privacy of children and adults should be properly examined before the Act is adopted. The article is behind a registration wall: the opening paragraph is all we read, so nothing beyond that sentence is taken from here
-
KontorBund — Germany's under-13 social media ban: the Cabinet's key-points paper of 14 October 2026 Our own note on the same paper: the four legislative and eight non-legislative measures, the interim rule, the d-you wallet, the SGB VIII and BGB changes, and what a small platform, forum, game or app should watch for
Tell us what we got wrong
This file will move. If you find the Commission's impact analysis, a Council position, a national implementation note, or a cost figure with a name attached to it, bring it in — a source we can open beats ten pages of commentary, and we will correct this page in public if it turns out we have something wrong.