KontorBund — Note
The EU copyright consultationLast checked 18 October 2026
kontorbund.com/notes/eu-copyright-consultation-2026.html
The EU copyright consultation: AI, piracy, performers' remuneration and research — responses by 3 November 2026
The short version
On 29 September 2026 the European Commission opened a targeted consultation on possible changes to EU copyright rules. It runs until 3 November 2026 and covers four areas: the use of protected content in generative AI, online piracy, the remuneration of performers and producers, and copyright in scientific research. It follows a call for evidence of 18 May 2026 and the review of the CDSM Directive, Directive (EU) 2019/790, required by its Article 30. The Commission has provisionally scheduled its review report and a possible legislative proposal for the first quarter of 2027. Nothing is law yet — the consultation is the moment to put evidence on the record.
What the Commission opened
The consultation sits on the Commission's consultations page under the heading Targeted consultation to support a better copyright environment for creativity and innovation, with the window 29 September 2026 to 3 November 2026. The questionnaire itself is headed Targeted consultation on a potential initiative for a better copyright environment for European creativity and innovation. Note the word "potential": the Commission is asking whether further EU copyright measures are needed, not defending a draft.
- The window — 29 September to 3 November 2026
- Both dates are the Commission's own, from its consultations listing. The consultation is the second step in the same file: a call for evidence ran from 18 May 2026 to 25 June 2026 under the title Commission seeks views on the review of EU copyright rules.
- What the call for evidence was for
- According to the IP Helpdesk's account of it, the earlier initiative had two objectives. The first was to gather information for the review of the CDSM Directive — Directive (EU) 2019/790 on copyright and related rights in the Digital Single Market — as required by Article 30 of that Directive. That review is to assess whether the Directive has improved access to protected content, licensing practices and remuneration for creators. The second objective was to identify problems that might require additional EU legislation.
- What Article 30 actually says
- Article 30(1) of Directive (EU) 2019/790: "No sooner than 7 June 2026, the Commission shall carry out a review of this Directive and present a report on the main findings to the European Parliament, the Council and the European Economic and Social Committee." Article 30(2) adds that the Member States shall provide the Commission with the necessary information for that report. The review clause is why this file is moving in 2026 and not earlier.
- Who is invited to respond
- The Commission invites copyright holders, creators, AI providers, online platforms, businesses, research institutions, consumer organisations and other interested parties. That is a wide list, and it is not addressed to rightholders alone.
- What it is not
- It is not legislation, and it does not change any date you are working to. The IP Helpdesk's account of the file has the Commission saying it "will use the responses to assess whether further EU copyright measures are needed". Whatever comes out of it would be a proposal first, and a proposal is not law.
The four topics
The Commission frames four areas. Each is a specific legal problem, not a slogan, and the paperwork behind it names the instruments involved.
- 1. Use of copyright-protected content in AI
- One of the main issues is the use of protected works to develop generative AI. The Commission recognises that existing EU legislation — the CDSM Directive and the AI Act — already provides certain safeguards, but says copyright holders may still face difficulties knowing how their works are used, licensing that use, and receiving appropriate remuneration. Possible measures named: improving access to information, facilitating licensing through mediation or arbitration, and new mechanisms to ensure appropriate remuneration for creators. A further option is to strengthen protection for performers against AI-generated imitations of their voices, appearance or performances. The Commission adds that the potential effects on AI developers, including start-ups and SMEs, will be taken into account.
- 2. Online piracy
- The focus is unauthorised streaming of sports competitions and other live events. The Commission's view is that existing enforcement measures may be insufficient, particularly because the commercial value of live content depends heavily on when it is available. Its assessment of the 2023 Recommendation on combating online piracy of sports and other live events found that it had not substantially reduced piracy. Possible responses: stronger enforcement measures, with appropriate safeguards, and closer cooperation between national authorities.
- 3. Remuneration of performers and producers — the non-EU question
- Under Article 8(2) of Directive 2006/115/EC, performers and phonogram producers are entitled to equitable remuneration when commercially published sound recordings are broadcast or played in public. Following the Court of Justice's judgment in Case C-265/19 (RAAP), the Commission has been assessing the imbalance created when performers and producers from non-EU countries receive remuneration in the EU even though their countries do not offer equivalent rights to EU performers and producers. One proposal under examination is a principle of material reciprocity, which would take account of the remuneration rights granted to EU nationals in those countries.
- 4. Copyright in scientific research
- Directive 2001/29/EC allows Member States to introduce an exception to copyright for scientific research, but differences between national laws can make cross-border collaboration difficult. Researchers may also face restrictions on sharing their published work after transferring rights to academic publishers. Possible changes: clarifying or further harmonising the research exception, and an EU-wide secondary publication right — which could allow researchers to publish their scientific works independently of the versions published by academic journals, subject to certain conditions.
Why the AI options matter
Two of the measures under examination — transparency about what went into a model and a licensing route with mediation or arbitration — are the two that would land on anyone building with generative models. The third, new remuneration mechanisms, decides how the money moves. None of them is law; all three would be shaped by the evidence in this file.
- Access to information is the sharp end
- The Commission's list of options opens with "improving access to information" — the rightholders' complaint being that they cannot tell whether a model used their work. The AI Act already obliges providers of general-purpose AI models to put in place a copyright policy — including identifying and complying with a reservation of rights under Article 4(3) of Directive (EU) 2019/790 — and to make publicly available a sufficiently detailed summary of the content used for training (Article 53(1), points (c) and (d)). The CDSM Directive already carries that text-and-data-mining reservation in Article 4(3). The consultation is about whether that is enough. Any measure that goes further reaches you as a deployer or a provider depending on what you actually do with the model.
- Licensing through mediation or arbitration
- This is the option that could make licensing cheap enough for a small shop to use: a collective or brokered route instead of a bilateral negotiation with a major rightholder, and a dispute step short of court. It also decides whether a licence you take covers a use you did not foresee. The Commission names it as a possible measure, not a decision.
- Remuneration mechanisms and performer imitations
- New remuneration mechanisms would allocate money to creators; stronger protection for performers against AI-generated imitations of voices, appearance or performances would sit alongside the Article 50 deep-fake disclosure duty in the AI Act. For a creator, this is the part of the consultation that is about a person's own voice and face. For a developer, it is a new question about which inputs you can accept, and on what basis.
- The Commission has written small developers into the file
- It states that the potential effects on AI developers, including start-ups and SMEs, will be taken into account. That is the sentence to hold the Commission to — and the reason a small operator's response is worth more here than a press release.
Our reading, not the Commission's
If nobody building small responds, the record on cost and feasibility will be written by large rightholders and large AI providers, and "the effects on start-ups will be taken into account" becomes a sentence about someone else. We have no evidence of what the Commission will propose; we have its list of options and its timetable. That is all this page claims.
What a respondent can put on the record
The consultation is a structured questionnaire, not an open mailbox. As the form renders, it is divided into these parts: Introduction; Identification; Copyright and generative AI, with two further blocks — licensing and enforcement of copyright and related rights, and AI-generated imitations of performers; online piracy of time-sensitive copyright-protected content; use in the EU of the sound recordings of nationals of non-EU countries; copyright and research; and additional documents.
- Answer the part that matches your situation
- A one-person software shop belongs in the AI part, and the licensing block is where the mediation and arbitration option sits. A creator whose voice or likeness is imitated belongs in the performers block. A researcher belongs in the research part. The form is long; we have not read its instructions on whether every part has to be answered.
- Bring numbers, not adjectives
- The Commission's questions are about whether measures are needed, so the evidence that helps is concrete: what a licence cost, how long clearing a right took, which notice you could not find, what you had to remove and when. An unsourced claim is worth little here; a dated, specific one is worth a lot. That is the same standard we hold ourselves to on this page.
- There is a section for additional documents
- The form ends with a part headed additional documents. We did not complete it, so we do not describe what it accepts.
- What we will not tell you
- We have not worked through the identification section of the questionnaire, so we do not say here what it asks for, whether a response can be made without identifying yourself, or whether responses are published. Open the form and read that part before you invest an afternoon in it.
What comes after 3 November
The Commission's stated use of the responses is to assess whether further EU copyright measures are needed. It has provisionally scheduled two things for the first quarter of 2027: the review report under Article 30, and a possible legislative proposal.
- The report is required; the proposal is not
- Article 30 obliges the Commission to carry out the review and present a report to the European Parliament, the Council and the European Economic and Social Committee. A legislative proposal is a policy choice on top of that, and the Commission's own wording is "possible". A file that ends with a report and no proposal is a real outcome.
- A proposal is still not law
- If a proposal comes, it goes to the European Parliament and the Council. Nothing would apply to your business on the day it is published, and nothing in this consultation moves a deadline you are working to now.
- What to do until then
- Keep the record you would want to submit: what you licence, from whom, at what price, and what you could not clear. If a proposal comes in 2027, that record is the difference between an opinion and a case.
What we could not establish
This page is built from the Commission's consultations listing, the questionnaire's own section headings, the IP Helpdesk's account of the file and the text of Article 30. Here is what that does not cover.
- The questions themselves
- We read the section structure of the questionnaire as it renders, not the wording of the individual questions or the possible answers. Do not treat the headings above as a list of what you will be asked.
- Whether responses are published, and in what form
- Neither the consultations listing nor the material we read says how individual contributions will be handled. We therefore say nothing about it.
- The call for evidence document itself
- We saw its window (18 May to 25 June 2026) and its title on the Commission's listing, and we have the IP Helpdesk's description of its two objectives, but we did not open the underlying call-for-evidence text.
- Anything beyond "first quarter of 2027"
- The provisional schedule is the only timing the Commission gives in the material we read. There is no draft text, no impact assessment we have seen, and no indication of which of the four areas would be legislated first.
- What it would cost you
- No figure exists to report, because no measure exists yet. Anyone quoting a compliance cost for this file is quoting a guess.
Sources
The dates and the four topics come from the Commission's own pages and from the questionnaire; the detail of the possible measures comes from the IP Helpdesk's account, which is an EU agency publication rather than a press summary.
-
European Commission (DG CONNECT) — Consultations Read 18 October 2026. Source for the consultation window 29 September 2026 – 3 November 2026 under the title "Targeted consultation to support a better copyright environment for creativity and innovation", and for the earlier call for evidence "Commission seeks views on the review of EU copyright rules", 18 May 2026 – 25 June 2026. The listing gives dates and titles only.
-
European Commission — the questionnaire (Targeted consultation on a potential initiative for a better copyright environment for European creativity and innovation) Opened 18 October 2026; the form itself. Source for the questionnaire's title and for its section structure: Introduction; Identification; Copyright and generative AI (with a licensing-and-enforcement block and an AI-generated-imitations-of-performers block); Online piracy of time-sensitive copyright-protected content; Use in the EU of the sound recordings of nationals of non-EU countries; Copyright and research; Additional documents. We did not complete the questionnaire, so the questions and answer options are not described here.
-
European IP Helpdesk (EISMEA) — European Commission seeks feedback on possible changes to EU copyright rules News blog, 16 October 2026, read in full. Source for the launch date of 29 September 2026 and the 3 November 2026 deadline; the four topics and their detail; the two objectives of the 18 May 2026 call for evidence; the CDSM Directive and AI Act safeguards and the three groups of possible AI measures plus the performers option; the statement that effects on AI developers including start-ups and SMEs will be taken into account; the 2023 Recommendation on combating online piracy of sports and other live events and the finding that it had not substantially reduced piracy; Article 8(2) of Directive 2006/115/EC and Case C-265/19 (RAAP) with the material-reciprocity option; the research exception under Directive 2001/29/EC and the secondary-publication-right option; the list of invited respondents; and the provisional first quarter of 2027 scheduling of the review report and a possible legislative proposal.
-
EUR-Lex — Directive (EU) 2019/790 (CDSM Directive) OJ L 130, 17.5.2019. Source for the text of Article 30 quoted above: paragraph 1 ("No sooner than 7 June 2026, the Commission shall carry out a review of this Directive and present a report on the main findings to the European Parliament, the Council and the European Economic and Social Committee") and paragraph 2 (Member States shall provide the Commission with the necessary information). Also the source for the Article 4(3) reservation of rights for text and data mining referred to in the AI section.
-
EUR-Lex — Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 (AI Act) Checked for the AI section only: the obligations on providers of general-purpose AI models in Article 53(1), points (c) and (d) — a policy to comply with Union copyright law, in particular to identify and comply with a reservation of rights expressed pursuant to Article 4(3) of Directive (EU) 2019/790, and a publicly available, sufficiently detailed summary of the training content.
-
EUR-Lex — Directive 2006/115/EC (rental and lending right, related rights) Source for Article 8(2): the right ensuring that a single equitable remuneration is paid by the user where a phonogram published for commercial purposes is used for broadcasting by wireless means or for any communication to the public, shared between the relevant performers and phonogram producers. We checked the provision itself, not the Commission's reading of it.
Tell us what we got wrong
If you answer the consultation, send us what it asked you — the questions, the identification section, what the additional-documents part accepts. A source we can open beats ten pages of commentary, and we will correct this page in public.